Friday, March 23, 2007

You're doin' my Nutt, man!

It seems that a group of scientists have decided to reclassify drugs.
Alcohol is ranked almost as harmful as heroin in a controversial new drug classification system proposed by a team of leading scientists.

The class A drug Ecstasy, possession of which can result in a seven-year prison sentence, is placed near the bottom of the league table which lists "harm scores" for different substances.

LSD, another class A drug, is also considered relatively safe despite its powerful hallucinogenic properties.

Cannabis, recently downgraded to class C, occupies a middle position. It is rated more dangerous than Ecstasy, LSD and the dance floor drug GHB, but less harmful than tobacco.

The table, published in The Lancet medical journal, was drawn up by a team of highly respected scientists led by Professor David Nutt, from the University of Bristol, and Professor Colin Blakemore, chief executive of the Medical Research Council.

It is intended to be a model for policy makers which is more scientifically based than the current Misuse of Drugs Act system that attaches "a, b, and c" labels to illicit drugs.

This eminently sensible list is based on a number of different criteria.
The scientists identified three main factors that together determined the harmfulness of a controlled substance.

These were: The physical harm to the individual user caused by the drug, the tendency of the drug to induce dependence, and the effect of the drug's use on families, communities and society.

One of my arguments has always been that (heroin aside) the stronger drugs tend to be less harmful because you cannot take them sustainably. One cannot spend one's whole time on Ecstasy, for instance, because one would find it damn near impossible to hold down a job; besides, the drug is self-limiting through the law of diminishing returns: the more one takes it, the less effect it has. This is one of the reasons that people tend to "grow out of" such substances.

However, alcohol and cigarettes (and, indeed, cannabis), for instance, can be taken very regularly over the period of decades and thus do more long-term harm. They also become more addictive, with the physical addiction supplemented by a habit-forming one.

Of course, I think we should just legalise, regulate and tax the whole lot of them since the vast majority of the damage that the illegal drugs do, to both individuals and society, derives mainly from their illegality...


Nicodemus said...

Quite right, Dear Devil. I for one believe that the decriminalise and prescribe outlook odious, as it determines that one's choice to use something to liberate ones mind or dance your kite off implies that Nanny thinks you are poorly in the bonce, and need 'treatment'. (That thought alone makes me shudder)
No - legalise everything - the hard sone self limit, but with low market rates (E costs no more than an aspirin) the crime associated wiht it disappears.
New Zealand sells dance drugs over the counter as a conter to E - with no ill effects.
If you take away people's ability to be self responsible - they just be come irresponsible.


Nicodemus said...

Apologies for typos in previous post.
Also see links on my page about the latest hysteria regarding BZP.

GCooper said...

Leaving aside the legalisation question, anyone who thinks LSD is 'safe' either didn't live through the 1960s - or lived through them rather too incautiously.

Gavin Ayling said...

It is not for the state to tell you what to do with your own body. If you choose to ingest harmful chemicals or kill yourself the state vehemently shouldn't help you, but it should also not prohibit you.

Anonymous said...

Heroin isn't particularly harmful. The channel 4 drugs week a few years ago interviewed a GP who confirmed this.

I know it's hard to believe after all the hysteria in the tabloids. Here's a wiki link.

Oh yeah? So what has happened for the last ten years, exactly?

Over at the ASI, they are posting some of the winning entries of the Young Writers on Liberty. One does not want to put such keen minds off,...