Sunday, November 06, 2011

This is science fiction...

Posted by Devil's Kitchen at 11/06/2011 04:32:00 pm

In an on-going argument with Martin Ford, Timmy (writing at Forbes) describes a situation that will be familiar to those who read a particular type of science fiction.
For a job, an income, isn’t in fact what any of us humans want. What we want is the ability to consume (consume houses, food, clothes, cars etc, all of which are now being made by machine recall) and and income and or a job are only methods of achieving that. So, if the machines are doing all of the work then, well, who is going to be consuming the output? As there’s only us human beings to do so I pretty much guess that it will be us human beings consuming all of the output. And if we’re able to consume all of this output being produced by the machines then why would we care about having a job or an income? We get to consume without either, don’t we?

All of our material needs are being fulfilled by the machines. We are thus able to be:
A farmer in the morning, a laborer in the afternoon, and a philosopher in the evening.

We’re able to be communists in short. Potter around growing a tomato or two in the morning (nothing quite like it for the spirit, to actually nurture and grow a plant then eat the produce), labour a little in the afternoon at that tennis backhand or lay the crazy paving (yes, the machine could and would do it better and faster but the spiritual rewards of hand work are, as we are told, considerable) and in the evening we can yammer with our friends over silliness (that is what philosophers do, yes, yammer with friends over sillinesses?).

A world in which the machines made everything would be a world in which there was no shortage of anything and in such a world what on earth would any of us actually desire a job for?

Of course, for anyone who has ever read any of Ian M Banks' Culture novels, this whole scenario will be entirely familiar.
The Culture is characterized by being a post-scarcity society (meaning that its advanced technologies provide practically limitless material wealth and comforts for everyone for free, having all but abolished the concept of possessions), by having overcome almost all physical constraints on life (including disease and death) and by being an almost totally egalitarian, stable society without the use of any form of force or compulsion, except where necessary to protect others.

And, indeed, it seems to be a rather desirable way in which to live. Although, having said that, most of The Culture novels are about how that society spends its time interfering in less developed societies...

Labels: , , ,

Posted by Devil's Kitchen at 11/06/2011 04:32:00 pm

9 Blogger Comments:

Blogger Tony Lorusso said...

Ironically, Marxism is, to put it charitably, unlikely to ever deliver a post scarcity world, and couldn't maintain one even if another system, say the free market, handed it one.

11/06/2011 06:38:00 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I love the Culture novels, but they do lend a fake credibility to the Marxist dream by creating a Humanist 'God' in the guise of the perfect moral caring Minds. The Minds not only fulfil the Marxist dream of being the infallible central planners, but also are the ultimate benevolent moral arbiters, protecting humanity and lesser species from bad behaviour (which has mostly been eugenically bred out of humanity). They also create and operate the hardware that allows this Marxist dream to exist.

Replace the science with magic and the Minds with God, and you have the perfect Marxist religious parable.

Banks has also backtracked on 'Intervention' as well. The do-gooding Culture of the earlier Player of Games (my favourite) is gone. Banks was troubled by Iraq you see. Not happy about 'cultures' intervening in shit holes. Too messy without those noble Minds to set us straight.

11/06/2011 08:40:00 pm  
Blogger Neal Asher said...

I was uncomfortable with the notion of 'noble minds' in my books, so scrutinised them a bit more closely. The AIs are essentially the post-humans and though certain human drives are missing, because they were created by humans many are still in place - the core of the AI mind being human, but much like our reptile back-brain, the AIs wanting to survive to consequently wanting more power and control.

11/07/2011 10:48:00 am  
Anonymous Skimmer said...

You have to hand it to banks for creating a truly inspiring depiction of utopia. He did a damn sight more convincing effort than any religion I’m aware off.

Although there is still a shadow pointed out by Hamilton’s Gore Burnelli railing that the Highers don’t know how to strive for anything anymore.

Making your AI’s ‘human’ (if more rational) certainly smacks of anthropomorphism – don’t I don’t see how far you can step away from that and still have a coherent character.
I think that to dodge the bullet allot of Si Fi writers largely leave the AI’s out, but for a single Token in each book, much like the black kid in South Park.

Btw Neal – loved the Skinner & Gridlinked.

11/07/2011 11:29:00 am  
Blogger Neal Asher said...

Thanks Skimmer.

I know what the Devil was getting at when he wrote 'Culture novels are about how that society spends its time interfering in less developed societies...' but it also tells you something about utopia: it's too boring to write about at length.

11/07/2011 04:04:00 pm  
Anonymous Skimmer said...

It certainly doesn’t lend itself to drama, without either the heaven being shook by external forces or the protagonists moved to a less enlightened setting.

Still, I really liked the concept of the virtual hells, even if the Culture was not moved to interfere directly.

And I was bowled over by Hamilton’s depiction of the far future in the Void Trilogy – weighty tombs, but the characterisation was breathtaking.

11/09/2011 01:28:00 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Devil

Fewer people required to make things and provide services releases huge amounts of time for everyone.

The evolution of our society has been hijacked by Big Government which squanders millions of man-years of people's time in fruitless and pointless non-jobs or at the bottom of the benefits trap.

Non-job holders occupy positions of power over subordinates and the welfare client classes and naturally tend to abuse them.

The biggest problem people have is: too much time, not enough to do.

The free market has been marginalised by government, preventing it from developing ways for people to use their time fruitfully and happily.

Things may change soon. Prosperity has been built on cheap energy, especially oil. Oil production has been at peak plateau since mid-2004 and will start terminal decline. I suspect the ‘carbon’ scam is a proxy for fossil energy, used by politicians too scared of the inevitable consequences of rapidly declining per capita energy in a civilisation grown accustomed to the fruits of cheap energy.

They say civilisation is three square meals from savagery.


11/10/2011 05:21:00 pm  
Anonymous mojo said...

Beg to differ - Humans (and close cognates) are definitely NOT in charge in the Culture. Mainly because they don't have the brains for it. The Minds run the place, and let their humans play at being in charge.

11/16/2011 09:30:00 pm  
Blogger DWMF said...

A perfect society will not be stable. Even moving round the same old fashion cycles will not be enough.

For the description of a lotus-eater culture, I prefer the Michael Moorcock "Dancers at the End of Time" books.


12/26/2011 03:57:00 pm  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home


  • "The best British political/libertarian blog on the web. Consistently excellent but not for the squeamish."—Christopher Snowdon
  • "[He] runs the infamous and fantastically sweary Devil’s Kitchen blog, and because he’s one of the naughtiest geeks (second only to the incredibly, incredibly naughty Guido Fawkes) he’s right at the top of the evil dork hierarchy."—Charlotte Gore
  • "I met the Devil's Kitchen the other night. What a charming young man he is, and considerably modest too..."—Peter Briffa
  • "The Devil's Kitchen exposes hypocrisy everywhere, no holds barred."—Wrinkled Weasel
  • "People can still be controversial and influential whilst retaining integrity—Devil's Kitchen springs to mind—and attract frequent but intelligent comment."—Steve Shark, at B&D
  • "Sometimes too much, sometimes wrong, sometimes just too much but always worth a read. Not so much a blog as a force of nature."—The Nameless Libertarian
  • "The Devil's Kitchen—a terrifying blog that covers an astonishing range of subjects with an informed passion and a rage against the machine that leaves me in awe..."—Polaris
  • "He rants like no one else in the blogosphere. But it's ranting in an eloquent, if sweary, kind of way. Eton taught him a lot."—Iain Dale
  • "But for all that, he is a brilliant writer—incisive, fisker- extraordinaire and with an over developed sense of humour... And he can back up his sometimes extraordinary views with some good old fashioned intellectual rigour... I'm promoting him on my blogroll to a daily read."—Iain Dale
  • "... an intelligent guy and a brilliant writer..."—A Very British Dude
  • "... the glorious Devil's Kitchen blog—it's not for the squeamish or easily offended..."—Samizdata
  • "... a very, smart article... takes a pretty firm libertarian line on the matter."—Samizdata
  • "By the way, DK seems to be on fucking good form at the moment."—Brian Mickelthwait
  • "Perhaps the best paragraph ever written in the history of human creation. It's our Devil on fine form."—Vindico
  • "Devil's Kitchen is the big name on the free-market libertarian strand of the British blogosphere... Profane rants are the immediate stand-out feature of DK's blog, but the ranting is backed up by some formidable argument on a wide range of issues particularly relating to British and European parliamentary politics, economics, and civil liberties."—Question That
  • "... an excellent, intelligent UK political blog which includes a great deal of swearing."—Dr Aubrey Blumsohn
  • "I like the Devil's Kitchen. I think it's one of the best written and funniest blogs in the business."—Conservative Party Reptile
  • "The. Top. UK. Blogger."—My Vast Right-Wing Conspiracy
  • "For sheer intelligence, erudition and fun, Iain Dale's Diary, Cranmer and Devil's Kitchen are so far ahead of the rest I don't see how they can figure in a top ten. They are the Beatles, Stones and Who of the blog world; the Astair, Bogart and Marlon Brando of the blog world; the Gerswin, Porter and Novello of the blog world; the Dot Cotton, Pat Butcher, Bette Lynch of the blog world..."—Wrinkled Weasel
  • "It's the blogging equivalent of someone eating Ostrich Vindaloo, washed down by ten bottles of Jamaican hot pepper sauce and then proceeding to breathe very close to your face while talking about how lovely our politicians are... But there's much more to his writing than four letter words."—Tom Tyler
  • "God bless the Devil's Kitchen... Colourful as his invective is, I cannot fault his accuracy."—Tom Paine
  • "The Devil's Kitchen is a life-affirming, life-enhancing blog ... This particular post will also lead you to some of the best soldiers in the army of swearbloggers of which he is Field Marshal."—The Last Ditch
  • "... underneath all the ranting and swearing [DK]'s a very intelligent and thoughtful writer whom many people ... take seriously, despite disagreeing with much of what he says."—Not Saussure
  • "... the most foul-mouthed of bloggers, Devils Kitchen, was always likely to provoke (sometimes disgust, but more often admiration)."—The Times Online
  • "The always entertaining Mr Devil's Kitchen..."—The Times's Comment Central
  • "Frankly, this is ranting of the very highest calibre."—The Nameless Libertarian
  • "I don't mean it literally, or even metaphorically. I just find that his atheism aside, I agree with everything the Devil (of Kitchen fame...) says. I particularly enjoy his well crafted and sharp swearing, especially when addressed at self righteous lefties..."—The Tin Drummer
  • "Spot on accurate and delightful in its simplicity, Devil's Kitchen is one of the reasons that we're not ready to write off EUroweenie-land just yet. At least not until we get done evacuating the ones with brains."—Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler
  • "This hugely entertaining, articulate, witty Scottish commentator is also one of the most foul-mouthed bloggers around. Gird up your loins and have a look. Essential reading."—Doctor Crippen
  • "The Devil's Kitchen is one of the foremost blogs in the UK. The DK is bawdy, foul-mouthed, tasteless, vulgar, offensive and frequently goes beyond all boundaries of taste and decency. So why on earth does Dr Crippen read the DK? Because he reduces me to a state of quivering, helpless laughter."—Doctor Crippen's Grand Rounds
  • "DK is a take-no-prisoners sort of libertarian. His blog is renowned for its propensity for foul-mouthed invective, which can be both amusing and tiresome by turns. Nevertheless, he is usually lucid, often scintillating and sometimes illuminating."—Dr Syn
  • "If you enjoy a superior anti-Left rant, albeit one with a heavy dash of cursing, you could do worse than visit the Devil's Kitchen. The Devil is an astute observer of the evils of NuLabour, that's for sure. I for one stand converted to the Devil and all his works."—Istanbul Tory
  • "... a sick individual."—Peter Briffa
  • "This fellow is sharp as a tack, funny as hell, and—when something pisses him off—meaner than a badger with a case of the bullhead clap."—Green Hell
  • "Foul-mouthed eloquence of the highest standard. In bad taste, offensive, immoderate and slanderous. F***ing brilliant!—Guest, No2ID Forum
  • "a powerfully written right-of-center blog..."—Mangan's Miscellany
  • "I tend to enjoy Devil's Kitchen not only because I disagree with him quite a lot of the time but because I actually have to use my brain to articulate why."—Rhetorically Speaking
  • "This blog is currently slamming. Politics certainly ain't all my own. But style and prose is tight, fierce, provocative. And funny. OK, I am a child—swear words still crack a laugh."—Qwan
  • "hedonistic, abrasive but usually good-natured..."—The G-Gnome
  • "10,000 words per hour blogging output... prolific or obsessive compulsive I have yet to decide..."—Europhobia
  • "a more favoured blog from the sensible Right..."—Great Britain...
  • "Devils Kitchen, a right thinking man indeed..."—EU Serf
  • "an excellent blog..."—Rottweiler Puppy
  • "Anyone can cuss. But to curse in an imaginative fashion takes work."—Liftport Staff Blog
  • "The Devil's Kitchen: really very funny political blog."—Ink & Incapability
  • "I've been laffing fit to burst at the unashamed sweariness of the Devil's Kitchen ~ certainly my favourite place recently."—SoupDragon
  • "You can't beat the writing and general I-may-not-know-about-being-polite-but-I-know-what-I-like attitude."—SoupDragon
  • "Best. Fisking. Ever. I'm still laughing."—LC Wes, Imperial Mohel
  • "Art."—Bob
  • "It made me laugh out loud, and laugh so hard—and I don't even get all the references... I hope his politics don't offend you, but he is very funny."—Furious, WoT Forum
  • "DK himself is unashamedly right-wing, vitriolic and foul mouthed, liberally scattering his posts with four-letter-words... Not to be read if you're easily offended, but highly entertaining and very much tongue in cheek..."—Everything Is Electric
  • "This blog is absolutely wasted here and should be on the front page of one of the broadsheets..."—Commenter at The Kitchen
  • "[This Labour government] is the most mendacious, dishonest, endemically corrupt, power-hungry, incompetent, illiberal fucking shower of shits that has ruled this country..."—DK


Campaign Links

All: Daily Reads (in no particular order)

Politics (in no particular order)

Climate Change (in no particular order)

General & Humour (in no particular order)

Mac,Design Tech & IT (in no particular order)