Tuesday, November 06, 2007

A conspiracy with no meeting of minds

Matthew Sinclair has a typically thoughtful and coherent post up on the subject of Liberal Conspiracy.
I'm not sure what interaction Liberal Conspiracy wants with right-wingers. At first I thought it must want to be a showcase for the best talent the left-wing blogosphere has to offer. Sort of like Comment is Free was originally intended to be. That intention is suggested by the ConservativeHome-like online magazine format and the fact that it has clearly been "marketed" pretty widely. If that is the intention then it could become a great place to go and find all my favourite left-wing bloggers to debate with. The site would want to attract right-wing comment so that the new ideas it purports to promote can be battle-hardened before heading out into the real world.

Unfortunately, one of its very first posts manages a combination of superficiality and self-righteousness that has utterly put me off the whole project. Apparently what Zohra really wants is to escape the real world with all those unpleasant and self-evidently wrong people who disagree - who she never discusses in any tone but utter disdainful incomprehension.

Indeed. Still, I have thought of a fun tagline for the site...
Liberal Conspiracy: a voluntary collective discussing how best the rest of the population may be kept in an involuntary collective.

OK, OK, it's a bit long-winded, but you get the gist...

5 comments:

wildgoose said...

A "voluntary collective with the aims of keeping everyone else in an involuntary collective".

Sheer genius!

chris said...

Based on the posts so far Paternalist Conspiracy might have been a more apt title.

mike power said...

Shorter Matt Sinclair:

I didn't like one of the posts on LC so I'm jolly well not going to play with them anymore, so there!

Matthew Sinclair said...

Mike,

I love your strategy. You can write up an argument in a childish fashion and then mock it for sounding childish. Brilliant.

Let's try it for Gandhi: "I don't like imperialism, I'm making my own pants, so there!"

It's pretty meaningless. You aren't actually exposing the essence of my post you're just creating a straw idiot in your own image.

mike power said...

Mummy, mummy, that pretentious man with his head up his bum is fwightening me!

Oo, and I think I just caught a whiff of the 'essence of your post'- bullshit, if I'm not mistaken.

Anyway, I really must dash, Postman Pat is about to start.

The Cuban Health System

The Cuban Medical system. Over at the ASI blog, Tim Worstall asks if the Cuban Health statistics are true . I can't comment as to th...