Tuesday, May 08, 2007

Talking bollocks with Oliver Leftwing

Letwin has laid out the Cameron Conservative vision; in essence it is simply a rather more succinct version of the speech that myself, Jackart and The Nameless One were so utterly unimpressed with.
First, a shift from an econocentric paradigm to a sociocentric paradigm. Secondly, a shift in the theory of the State from a provision-based paradigm to a framework-based paradigm.

Like the speech that we listened to, it is heavy on rhetoric and rather light on concrete substance; a bit like Cameron himself, really.
To win a battle of ideas is always a hard task. But having an idea is certainly a good starting point.

Yeah, but an idea is not enough, Ollie; you need to be able to tell people who you intend to achieve these, really rather nebulous, "paradigm-shifts" and "intuitions".

You need to actually have decent concrete ideas that can be backed up by hard evidence, do you see? And you lost any confidence that I may have had in you when you essentially dismissed my well-researched reply to your fatuous three reasons for remaining in the EU with the following devastating riposte.
I am sorry that you and I do not agree about this matter - but I fear that we shall have to agree to differ.

Ollie, our membership of the EU is about economics, politics and sociology; it's not a question of fucking faith, you twat. We aren't discussing an unprovable issue, like whether or not a god exists.

Given Ollie's inability to discuss or provide justification for his position on such a relatively simple aspect of a fairly concrete issue, how useful do you think the Tory policies are likely to be in bringing this rather wishy-washy (and complicated to implement) philosophy to practical fruition?

I'm not holding my breath...

6 comments:

Roger Thornhill said...

"from provision-based paradigm to a framework-based paradigm"

Oh, from a State monopoly to a State-commissioned private monopoly more like, i.e. pure NewLabour. More inefficient, more corrupt.

Alan Douglas said...

Good heavens, so those words actually MEANT something ?

Alan Douglas

GCooper said...

It might be a start if Leftwing learned to speak English.

It's babble. Just babble.

AntiCitizenOne said...

Most people who use the word "paradigm" couldn't specify or design their way out of a paper bag.

Time to worry.

Mind you I quite like a concept I came up with and named "Citizen Oriented Government" COG. It sees thestate as a "base class" provider which individuals can over-ride by opting out of state systems.

chris said...

Some of the ideas in there are not that bad. He just buried them under haft a tonne of post-modern bullshit.

Roger Thornhill said...

I managed to find my own special "track changes on screen" button for the BBC story of Ollie Letwind's recent puff.

He was ribbed in PMQs today as well. It is a shame how someone "almost too clever" has been passed the Kameron Kool-Aid (raspberry flavour) and imbibed. His brain seems to have shrunk Alice-like.

One day he will find out what has happened and complain to Cameron, who will likely chuckle "eat me".

The Cuban Health System

The Cuban Medical system. Over at the ASI blog, Tim Worstall asks if the Cuban Health statistics are true . I can't comment as to th...